OUTLAWS： Hasidic Police, Above the Law
Stream Summary
This episode of Outlaws features an extended discussion on Hasidic and Orthodox Jewish community practices regarding law enforcement, internal governance, and parallel justice systems in the United States, particularly in New York. Through commentary, archival news clips, and a lengthy seminar presentation by a rabbi, the hosts examine religious prohibitions against cooperating with secular authorities, the role of volunteer Hasidic patrol organizations, and multiple criminal cases involving abuse, bribery, and cover‑ups. The discussion expands into broader themes of ethnic solidarity, state funding, selective law enforcement, and the implications of parallel legal structures operating alongside American institutions. The episode concludes with audience interaction, sponsor messages, and commentary on films and cultural references.
- Hasidic and Orthodox prohibitions against reporting crimes to secular authorities
- The religious concept of mesirah (informing on another Jew)
- Rabbinical authority versus state law
- Hasidic civilian patrol groups (e.g., Shomrim/Shmira)
- New York police cooperation with community patrols
- Criminal cases involving bribery, gun permits, and sexual abuse
- Use of public funds to support private community policing
- Media discussion, documentaries, and film references
- Live audience interaction and hyperchats
Sources
Key Points of Wisdom
-
[00:11:37]
“Mesirah exists to prevent Jews from handing fellow Jews over to non‑Jewish authorities—even when crimes are involved.”
Context: Explanation of religious prohibitions discussed in the rabbinical seminar.
-
[00:26:43]
“Whether someone goes to jail is not a question for the state—it’s a question for the rabbi.”
Context: Discussion of parallel authority structures.
-
[00:33:17]
“These aren’t alternative justice systems—they’re mechanisms to avoid justice altogether.”
Context: Commentary on internal community handling of crimes.
-
[01:14:05]
“We are funding institutions that exist to shield themselves from the very laws we’re expected to obey.”
Context: Discussion on public funding and nonprofit security grants.
Hyperchat Highlights
-
[1:27:57] righteous muffin:
“I'll listen tomorrow. Thanks for what you do and the team. If only Devin had agreed eight years ago.”
-
[1:28:19] Aggie jet pilot:
“We'll have to watch the replay later, but holy smoke, show blonde Batman with that intro screen. If that's what the end of society looks like, I say, bring it.”
-
[1:28:34] Lake:
“Great show you guys rock. You rock.”
-
[1:28:57] romega:
Large dono: “Devin, have you seen the movie Punishment Park? You should look it up… right up your alley.”
-
[1:29:45] Mr. Smitherins:
“Have you heard of the Krasner trial? There was a real life Oscar Schindler and the Israelis thanked him by assassinating him. Are you familiar with this?”
-
[1:30:07] Pride Assassin:
Brief message of support and thanks for the show.
-
[1:30:23] HWP:
“Keep up the fight.”
-
[1:50:58] scribble saga:
Simple thank‑you dono.
-
[1:51:10] white gun nationalist:
“Here are some dollars from Texas. Next week, this super chat will be in Hindi rofl.”
-
[1:51:27] Vincent pen Dragon:
Supportive dono; thanks to both hosts.
-
[1:52:09] HWP (again):
“Keep up the good fight.”
-
[1:53:32] Team White (Rumble):
“I like the new time slot.”
-
[1:53:57] likes to watch (Rumble):
“Forgot about the time slot change, catching up now. Have a good night.”
-
[1:54:15] Denise the Celt (Rumble):
“Jews are crazy and I believe evil on a genetic level, but they do unequivocally teach us that ethnic solidarity and exclusion of the other gets you everything.”
-
[1:54:52] mohawk (Rumble):
“When I think about our demographic situation, I can't help but feel like we're fucked. Our only hope at this point is to concentrate in one location and seize control. What are your thoughts on that?”
-
[1:55:43] Sacco possums (Rumble):
“Just a little fuel to keep the fire going. Less than 10 gallons of diesel nowadays though. Thanks and have a totally kind day.”
-
[1:56:12] cage motion jaro (Rumble):
“Non participation in the ideologies pushed on us is the most important thing. Highly recommending the book Anti-Politics by Whiteflings Publishing…”
-
[1:56:44] Ray flex (Rumble):
“Great show. Glad Churro is doing well.”
-
[1:57:27] YoJimbo Rockford (Rumble):
“I like the new time slot. I can catch a little bit on my lunch break instead of scrambling before my shift begins. Here's a little money because I like to see good people do good things.”
-
[1:58:13] clan caster (Entropy):
“JFG’s mummy sex bit was out of control hilarious.”
-
[1:58:44] clan caster (Entropy):
“I was close to pulling the trigger on the Backlash black tie weekend. Glad I did not, but hope something IRL can happen down the road in the Seattle area. Need Devin there, of course.”
-
[1:59:34] FUBAR nation (Entropy):
“Love the Antelope Hill commercial.”
-
[2:00:06] I'm an interpreter for nigs (Entropy):
“Whenever I stay at an Airbnb and a Normie forgets to log out of their YouTube, I make sure I put you guys in their history.”
-
[2:00:43] clan caster (Entropy):
“I have found new artists from your intros over the years… thought Blizzard Summer was a real band.”
-
[2:01:39] clan caster (Entropy):
“I’m game for a fundraiser event like that.”
-
[2:02:41] clan caster (Entropy):
“This is way past due support for both of you.” (Very generous dono.)
-
[2:03:43] YoJimbo Rockford (Rumble):
“I meant to say I like to see good people do good things. Now I have to scramble back to work.”
Hyperchat Contributors
- righteous muffin
- Aggie jet pilot
- Lake
- romega
- Mr. Smitherins
- Pride Assassin
- HWP
- scribble saga
- white gun nationalist
- Vincent pen Dragon
- Team White
- likes to watch
- Denise the Celt
- mohawk
- Sacco possums
- cage motion jaro
- Ray flex
- YoJimbo Rockford
- clan caster
- FUBAR nation
- I'm an interpreter for nigs